THE CATEGORY
CABINET

They closed by agreeing Butler clearly won the movie.

They agree Stallone wins the movie.

They agree Ferrell won the movie, while acknowledging McKay’s contribution.

The room cannot settle on a single winner, landing on a Cameron-versus-Weaver split with Paxton as a personal favorite.

They explicitly choose Sandra Bullock as the movie's winner, with a nod that Keanu is also in the conversation.

They debate the leads, but the final answer is that Jim Belushi won the movie.

They finish by agreeing that the Mini Coopers are the thing that wins the movie.

Bill says Peter Cetera is who the movie is remembered for, while Kyle gives the actual win to Marita.

They agree Will Smith wins the movie, with Kevin James making a strong case as the closest challenger.

Bill and the others ultimately credit Mann's style as the reason they keep returning to the movie, while also noting Foxx as a strong on-viewing winner.

They give Vaughn the win for being the most entertaining presence, while praising Matt O'Leary's performance too.

They explicitly name Rebecca De Mornay as the movie's winner.

They conclude that Jennifer Jason Leigh wins the movie, though Bridget Fonda is praised as the era's defining presence.

They end by giving the overall win to Sacha Baron Cohen.

The hosts unanimously treat Downey as the clear winner of the movie.

After considering Stiller, Diaz, and Dillon, they ultimately choose Cameron Diaz as the person who won the movie.

They close by declaring Arnold the winner of the movie.

They close by agreeing that Sharon Stone is the movie's biggest winner.

By the end they decide the band and its songs are the real winners, with HBO’s cable replay value also credited.

They agreed Petersen is the movie’s winner because the role launched his career and the whole film centers on him.

They conclude that Minnesota itself is the big winner of the film’s portrayal and legacy.

They conclude Sheridan is the real winner because the film launches him into a major long-term career trajectory.

They conclude Brosnan won the movie, while noting the franchise itself also benefits from the film’s success.

They explicitly agree that Fincher won the movie, though they also note Zodiac’s myth got a boost from the film.

The final winner pick is Billy Jacoby, with a side mention of Warren Beatty.

They agree Michelle Pfeiffer wins the movie.

They end by giving the win to Kosinski, arguing the movie means the most for his career.

They close by giving the win to Rob Reiner rather than Cusack.

The hosts choose Jack Black as the film’s winner because the role helped define his career, though Cusack gets significant credit too.

They close the rundown by naming Beatty as the movie’s winner.

All three hosts ultimately give the movie to Pacino, with McConaughey getting some support as well.

Bill gives the win to LeBrock for holding the whole movie together, while Kyle leans toward Hall.

When they closed with the winner, they gave the movie to Jim Carrey rather than Weir.

Bill explicitly picked Redford as the movie’s winner for closing out that creative renaissance with this film.

They ended by giving the movie win to Redford.

They concluded Redford won the movie, arguing he comes out smelling like gold even though Newman is terrific.

They agree Leslie Nielsen won overall because the role changed his career, with Stucker also earning major praise.

By the end, they settle on Costner as the overall winner because the movie is built around his star vehicle.

They explicitly name Coogler as the overall winner, with Jordan close behind.

Bill and Craig both identify James Caan as the movie’s winner.

They ended by saying Heath Ledger won the movie, and that the film is defined by his performance and legacy.

They explicitly gave the movie to Natasha Henstridge, with Madsen discussed as the alternate.

All three hosts pick Alec Baldwin as the movie's winner.

In the closing judgment, they say Scorsese won because the film got him back on track creatively.

They ultimately give the win to Samuel L. Jackson because the film boosts him from star turn to major franchise-level force.

Roger Ebert's take is read aloud and the room agrees Melanie Griffith won the movie.

They give the movie to Seagal overall because his performance and this era led to Under Siege and peak-watchability.

At the end-of-episode wrap-up, they say Bronson won the movie even if the performance is somewhat one-note.

They close by declaring Charles Bronson the winner of the movie.

Bill lands on Mimi Rogers as the winner, while acknowledging Bracco as the other major standout.

They conclude Seth Green probably won the movie for lasting recognition and career momentum, with Embry as the sentimental alternative.

The room ultimately says the movie belongs to Damon and Affleck together because they wrote it, starred in it, and made it happen.

After some back-and-forth, the hosts end by saying Shaq is the movie’s biggest winner.

The consensus is that Tony Scott’s direction is the real winner, with Duvall close behind as the key performance.

At the end, they picked Fred Willard as the movie's winner, with Higgins as the main alternate.

They say Stallone clearly won the movie as writer, star, and breakout creator of the franchise.

They agree Mike Myers is the main winner because of how well the movie serves his comedy and career.

At the end, they agree the movie is won jointly by Belushi and Aykroyd.

They mostly credited Gudegast, while also joking that the movie itself may have won by exceeding expectations.

They conclude that Peter Berg wins because the film leads directly to the TV series and shapes the franchise.

Bill picks screenwriter William Monahan, while Chris makes a case for Goodman, who is ultimately framed as the movie's key force.

They end by choosing Demi Moore as the movie’s ultimate winner because she gets the most out of the film’s provocative material.

They choose Crystal because the film helped establish him as a movie star while Hines was already the bigger physical presence.

They agree De Niro is the winner, with Stiller as a possible alternative.

They named Ari Aster as the winner because the film’s success gave him the career runway for later projects, while also saluting Collette.

The group agreed Hopkins won the movie overall, even while saying Foster deserved the Oscar.

They decide JoBeth Williams most strongly carries the movie, while acknowledging Spielberg got the larger share of credit.

They say the filmmakers and the audience won, though the cast did not financially benefit much.

They conclude that arm wrestling itself is the big winner because the film made the sport memorable for decades.

They ended by naming Michael Keaton the winner of the movie.

They ultimately say Notre Dame wins the movie, though they note Goldsmith's score is the other major winner.

They gave the overall movie win to Wes Anderson, while acknowledging Fiennes' performance as Oscar-worthy.

They give the win to Stiller because the movie cemented White Goodman as an iconic character and boosted his run.

They said Tarantino won the movie overall, with Jackson as the runner-up because of his towering performance.

They crowned Costner as the movie's winner, with Will Patton getting an honorable mention from the producer.

In the final wrap-up they agree Hugh Grant wins the movie, while also noting Julia Roberts and Richard Curtis as notable winners.

The episode ends with James Cameron getting the overall win for making the movie work at scale.

They agree Costner wins the movie overall, with Vin Scully acknowledged as a strong honorable mention.

At the end, they say the tornadoes won the movie, while also praising Hoffman as the performance that will age into the most fascinating one.

They ended by naming Mike Myers the overall winner of the movie, while acknowledging Heather Graham and Rob Lowe as notable secondary winners.

They agreed Leslie Nielsen won the movie because the role turned him into a true movie star and spawned sequels.

Bill says the dad won the movie, while Sean argues Sandler won it for his career and production-company launch.

They ultimately give the movie to Walter Matthau, while acknowledging Tatum O'Neal as a strong alternative.

They debate a few candidates, but settle most comfortably on Indiana as the big winner of the film.

At the end they explicitly agree that Paul Newman wins the movie.

At the end, they crown Sean Penn as the movie's winner.

They name Michael J. Fox as the winner, while also crediting Doc Brown’s character as a major reason the movie works.

They conclude Hoffman is the lasting winner of the movie because his performance is what people remember most.

They ultimately gave the win to Schrader, while acknowledging George C. Scott’s powerful performance.

They explicitly declare Tom Cruise the winner of Magnolia.

They ultimately give the edge to Turner because she has the bigger, funnier, and more varied role.

They decide the director wins for making a strong, memorable prison-crime thriller and effectively launching this subgenre.

The room leans slightly toward Coogler/Kugler, though they acknowledge a split with Stallone.

After debate, the room awards the movie to Harrison Ford over Tommy Lee Jones.

At the end they agree Pacino is the clear winner of the movie.

The hosts unanimously name Denzel Washington as the winner of the movie, not Hanks or Demi.

The hosts ultimately pick Jennifer Lawrence as the winner of the movie, while acknowledging Bradley Cooper as the soul of it.

At the end of the rundown, they explicitly award the movie to Denzel Washington.

They conclude that Josh wins the movie, though one host also credits chess itself.

They close by saying Barkin is the clear winner of the movie because she is its sex, soul, and center.

They ultimately chose Aniston as the biggest winner in the post-breakup aftermath, with Pitt as a plausible alternate answer.

At the end, the hosts agree that Richard Gere is the movie's winner, with Winger as the main alternate answer.

Rickman is declared the winner because the movie would not work with a lesser villain, though Costner is also discussed in relation to the film’s success.

After briefly considering evil as the winner, they land on Gregory Peck as the movie's strongest presence.

They close by naming Malkovich as the overall winner because his performance drives the movie.

They debate a few candidates, but Carpenter is treated as the overall winner of the movie.

They agree Sean Astin clearly won the movie and is the standout performance.

Bill and the others conclude Kasdan wins because the movie feels like a deeply personal generational classic.

They agree the movie belongs most to Palminteri, with C mentioned as a possible but lesser alternative.

They say Viola Davis wins the movie because her performance makes the whole film pop.

They agree that Murray wins the movie, even while acknowledging Coppola’s directing triumph.

When they ask who won the movie, the room answers Denzel.

They close by agreeing that Sarah Michelle Gellar wins the movie because she is so strong and memorable in every scene she's in.

They conclude that Kubrick won because the movie somehow worked and delivered a final unforgettable line, while jokingly crediting the Illuminati in passing.

The room ends by giving the movie itself to Chevy Chase.

The hosts unanimously declare Tom Cruise the winner of the movie.

They ended by agreeing that Al Pacino won the movie.

They end by saying DiCaprio won the movie, while still feeling he should have won for The Departed that year.

After considering both leads, Jennifer Lawrence lands on Jeff Daniels as the movie's winner for her.

They credited the Bond franchise as the main winner, while noting Mads Mikkelsen’s stealthy villain performance.

They split the win between Sevigny and Beckinsale, with both women viewed as the movie's central force.

They agree Favreau wins the movie, with Roy Choi and the various food elements also treated as winners.

They close by choosing Redford's Gage as the movie's winner.

After some back-and-forth, they land on Ray Allen as the movie’s winner because it permanently elevated his cultural status.

They conclude that Blumhouse wins because the movie helped establish the company’s model and brand.

They ultimately give the movie to Damien Chazelle as the director and author of the whole project.

They close by agreeing Meg Ryan is the winner of the movie, while Nora Ephron is also credited for the film's larger impact.

Both Chris and Bill land on Burt Reynolds as the winner, with the setting and landscapes also credited.

When they close by naming the winner, Hawk gets the final nod over the score.

They debate the career impact but settle on Giamatti as the movie's winner, with Payne as a close alternate case.

At the end they agree Michael Rooker is the movie's winner over Stallone.

They close by agreeing that Will Smith won the movie.

They agreed Denzel won the movie, with Dakota Fanning and Tony Scott also receiving major praise.

They close by naming John Candy the winner of the movie.

The room says De Palma wins overall, even while calling this Travolta’s best performance.

The room concludes that Gere is the ultimate winner because the role launched him into superstardom.

They ultimately declare Bart the Bear the movie’s winner, though Hopkins is the human alternative they discuss.

The hosts agree Danny McBride is the winner for the movie, while also noting Seth Rogen’s long-term cultural and business upside.

After a producer tiebreaker, they go with Jack Lemmon as the movie's winner.

The hosts agree Rebel Wilson wins the movie because she is the funniest and most entertaining presence throughout.

They close by giving the overall win to JC Chandor for pulling off such a difficult movie on a tiny schedule and budget.

In the final winner check, they give the movie to Spielberg, with Hanks as the next-strongest answer.

Both hosts agree Kurt Russell is the movie's winner and the most watchable part of the whole thing.

They close by saying Pacino won the movie, while noting Hoffman also benefits a lot from the experience.

The room names Travolta as the winner of the movie, while noting Olivia Newton-John also benefited enormously from it.

Bill and Juliet each landed on different winners, but the room’s final consensus favored Brendan Fraser over Matt Damon.

They conclude that the soundtrack edges out Pac for the overall win if the soundtrack is eligible.

They explicitly give the movie to Kathy Bates, with Reiner mentioned as the other big winner by implication.

They close by saying the music, the film, and even humanity can all be seen as winners, so the category is effectively shared.

Bill picks Connery, Craig also picks Connery, and Chris agrees Costner's case is strong but not enough to beat him.

They agree Rogen wins because the movie made him a bona fide leading man and writing star.

They concluded Mr. T won the movie, with strong supporting arguments for Talia Shire and a nod to Hulk Hogan.

They give the overall win to Spielberg, with E.T. also mentioned as a symbolic runner-up.

They say Murphy is the clear answer, though Tony Scott and the Rosewood-Taggart pairing get credit for strong resumes.

They name Sony as the biggest long-term winner, with Maguire as the short-term winner and the MCU as the broader franchise winner.

The hosts agree that Fincher is the clear winner because the movie only works at this level because of his direction.

They ultimately say Mark Wahlberg wins the movie, with Danny Glover getting a brief honorable mention.

They agree DiCaprio wins the movie, with Cameron close behind but Leo getting the final edge.

The hosts agree Nicholson won the movie, with a small case made for Burton.

At the end of the rundown, they agree Joan Allen is the overall winner, with Ang Lee also receiving strong consideration.

Bill leans toward Ron Howard, but the final call in the room goes to Steve Martin for showing the full range of the film's comedy and emotion.

After some back-and-forth, they settle on Rosemarie DeWitt as the movie's winner over Anne Hathaway.

They ultimately give the movie to Sutherland for the key performance, while noting Redford’s larger victory through directing and awards.

The hosts ultimately settle on Sharon Stone as the person who most won the movie.

They end by saying Kurt Russell clearly wins the movie.

Bill and Van split slightly, but the room’s consensus is that Tupac won the movie while Omar Epps gets credit for the film’s lasting impact.

The episode ends with a straightforward consensus that Bradley Cooper won the movie.

They explicitly say Steve Martin won the movie.

They give the movie to Damon Wayans, arguing that his performance is the film's best star turn and the key to the movie working.

They conclude Travolta wins the movie, while acknowledging the Bee Gees and Robert Stigwood as major beneficiaries too.

They agree Oliver Stone won the movie, with a brief alternative argument made for Lee Harvey Oswald.

Both hosts say Hackman won the movie for them.

Bill says Margot Robbie wins because she dominates the movie's chemistry, while Wesley makes a case for the stunt driver in the crash sequence.

They conclude that Mel Gibson won the movie overall.

The room explicitly picks Paul Newman as the movie's winner, citing his performance and the overdue Oscar acclaim.

They split between Scorsese’s career victory and DiCaprio’s performance, so the segment ends as a tie rather than a clean consensus.

They give the overall win to Danny Boyle for the film's vision, while praising McGregor as the movie's electric center.

Both hosts settle on Nolte as the actor who most carries the movie emotionally.

They agree G-Baby is the movie's winner because his death and memory drive the film's lasting impact.

After debating Hoffman, Cruise, and Levinson, they mostly land on Cruise as the movie's winner because the story hinges on his arc.

They agree that Affleck wins the movie because he directs and stars in it while also reestablishing his career.

They agree that Rogen and Goldberg won the movie because they created it, built the career launchpad, and made the whole era possible.

The hosts split slightly, but Pele gets the edge for making soccer feel iconic and for the movie’s lasting legacy.

They close by saying Whitney Houston clearly won the movie, with Costner still praised but secondary.

They agree Pitt won the movie because his performance most visibly elevates it every time he appears.

They unanimously pick Will Smith as the movie's winner, even while acknowledging Pullman's speech as a major factor in the film's success.

The hosts gave the overall win to John Singleton, with strong support also going to Ice Cube and a mention of Fishburne.

They close by saying Bill Murray clearly won the movie with his performance.

They ultimately give the movie to Spielberg, citing the film's impact, his profit participation, and the way it powered the rest of his career.

The hosts agree Nolan won by making a $5 million movie that looked far more expensive and put him on the map.

They ultimately agree Scorsese wins the movie because Goodfellas crowns his career and legacy.

Van ultimately votes for Joe Pesci, while Chris says Gibson wins but the title is effectively vacated and Pesci makes the movie.

They explicitly declare Bill Murray the winner of the movie.

Arnold is named the official winner, though Kyle makes a strong case for Bill Duke as the real soul of the movie.

They agree Robin Williams won the movie, and then briefly rank his broader performances after that.

They give the win to Mel Gibson and Danny Glover as a duo because their chemistry carries the film and elevated both of their profiles.

After some back-and-forth, the hosts vote for James Caan as the movie’s winner over Prosky and even Mann himself.

They end by agreeing that Arnold Schwarzenegger is the clear winner of Commando.

Bill initially names the score and then settles on James Wan, while Sean makes a case for Lynn Shaye and Chris mentions Rose Byrne.

They land on Spike as the overall winner, with Denzel also getting a strong post-heat-era appreciation.

All three hosts land on Rose Byrne as the movie's winner.

They conclude Roberts won the movie, while noting Bergen’s villain and the era’s hockey-player look as strong contenders.

Bill, Sean, and Bill Hader split on De Niro, Jodie Foster, and Scorsese, so no single winner emerges.

They conclude that Soderbergh wins overall because the movie re-established him as a commercial filmmaker and shaped the rest of his career.

They close by saying Schwarzenegger wins the movie because it is a great performance and his signature star vehicle.

They close by declaring Arnold the winner of the movie.

They agree Stallone wins the movie by a landslide because the film made him a huge action star and launched the Rambo franchise.

Chris chooses Gene Hackman and Andy chooses Luke Wilson, with both treating their pick as the film's ultimate winner.

They closed by agreeing McCarthy won the movie because her breakout performance turned her into a star, even though Wiig was the lead and co-writer.

The room initially lands on Gwyneth, with Bill offering Garrett Hedlund as a strong alternate winner because of the career-boosting potential of the role.

They agree Douglas won the movie, with Stone as a credible alternate winner for making the film and defining the era.

They agree Phoenix wins the movie because Max California gives it energy and makes the whole thing pop.

All three hosts agree Woody is the character whose choices and growth define the movie most.

The hosts disagree at first, but ultimately settle on Sorkin as the biggest winner because the film established him as a major screenwriter.

They finish by saying Friedkin won the movie, with the film’s success defining his career peak even if it also complicated his later reputation.

They conclude Lundgren's Drago is the film's biggest winner, with one joking aside that America might have won instead.

Bill, Chris, and Craig all ultimately picked Keaton as the movie's winner despite praising Ruffalo's performance.

Sean Bean is named the winner of the movie because of how much his character drives the NASA side of the story, though Damon is also praised heavily.

The hosts end by agreeing that Noah Baumbach is the movie’s overall winner for making such a sharp debut at 25.

The hosts ultimately choose Sean Penn as the winner because his part is the most essential and electric piece of the movie.

They ultimately agree Fincher is the winner, while also noting Freeman’s performance as a strong secondary case.

They closed by declaring Emma Stone the clear winner and the cornerstone of the film’s success.

They closed by saying Diane Lane won the movie and their hearts.

They close by giving the movie to Christopher McQuarrie for the screenplay and its lasting impact, while noting Spacey was the original 1995 answer.

They conclude Raul won the movie because he carries the emotional arc and most of the best moments.

They explicitly named Tom Cruise as the movie's winner, while giving Coughlin a strong honorable mention.

They close by agreeing that Judd Apatow won the movie through the film’s success and its launch of his comedy era.

Bill and Andy both ultimately picked Samantha Mathis/Nora De Niro as the movie’s winner over Christian Slater.

They agree Will Smith won the movie overall because it launched him into true movie-star status.

After some discussion, Craig and Bill both land on Ham as the movie's winner, overtaking the usual Benny-the-Jet instinct.

The final consensus is Whoopi Goldberg, with Swayze also getting strong support for anchoring the whole movie.

Bill and Chris land on Lily Taylor, while Sean goes with Vera Farmiga, making it a split decision.

They ultimately give the movie to Spike Lee for his restrained but powerful directing job, with Prieto and Terence Blanchard also praised.

They ultimately give the movie to River Phoenix, while acknowledging Reiner’s case through Castle Rock’s later success.

They end by choosing Favreau as the ultimate winner because the film launched his career and set up his long-term Hollywood rise.

They end by naming Demi Moore and Rob Lowe as co-winners, with Judd Nelson close behind.

Bill gives the movie to Mark Wahlberg, while Chris gives it to Wolfgang Petersen for directing the set pieces and pacing.

They directly name Chevy Chase as the clear winner, with Dana Wheeler-Nicholson discussed as the runner-up.

The hosts mostly give the victory to Cameron Crowe for launching the film and shaping the genre, with Cusack and Peter Gabriel also mentioned as worthy contenders.

Van picks Halle Berry, Wesley picks Eddie Murphy, and the discussion frames Halle as the movie’s biggest overall beneficiary.

At the end, Billy Bob Thornton is declared the overall winner of the movie by the room, with a dissenting homer pick for Will Patton.

In the closing winner discussion, the hosts pick Michael J. Fox as the person who won the movie because the replacement casting made the film work.

They close by saying Costner clearly wins the movie because the whole thing works on his charisma.

The room settled on Denzel Washington as the film’s winner for establishing himself as a major movie star.

They explicitly name Bill Murray as the winner of the movie and the key reason it works.

Kurt Russell is named the overall winner of the movie, with Romero and Carpenter also getting honorable mention praise.

They land on Frankenheimer as the winner, with Mamet and De Niro discussed as alternatives but not the final choice.

They conclude that Hughes is the real winner because the film crystallizes him as the defining 1980s writer-director, with Broderick close behind.

They explicitly agree that Sanaa Lathan won the movie because her performance captures the film’s central emotional and thematic weight.

Everyone explicitly agrees that Sharon Stone won the movie.

They agree Hackman wins the movie, while Bonet is treated as the biggest overall scene-stealer.

They end by crediting Arnold for the movie’s success, while also crediting Verhoeven for pulling off the film’s difficult execution.

The episode closes by explicitly naming Chris Farley as the movie’s winner.

They end by agreeing that Paul Walker is the movie's winner.

After weighing Macchio, Morita, and Zabka, they decided Zabka's long-term staying power made him the winner.

They debate Cruise, Blunt, and Liman, but never land on a clean final winner.

He closes by saying Tom Hanks clearly won the movie.

After some back and forth, they co-award the movie to Soderbergh and Europe rather than a single cast member.

They split personal favorites, but the room settles on Matthew Modine as the movie's winner for carrying the lead role.

They agree Ice Cube gets the win because his character is the most resolved and memorable by the end.

They split between Pitt, DiCaprio, and Tarantino, but the room ultimately gave the win to Brad Pitt.

They first agree Tony Scott won the movie, then Quentin makes a case that the train itself also deserves the win.

They agree the movie belongs to Christopher Nolan even while noting several strong secondary winners.

The room agreed that Adam Sandler was the overall winner, with Carl Weathers mentioned as another major beneficiary.

After debating Mendes, Bardem, and the Broccoli family, they agree the franchise and Bond himself are the ultimate winners.

At the end, they explicitly named Jude Law as the movie's winner.

After debating Butler versus Schreiber, they land on Schreiber as the film’s winner.

They agree Michael Keaton wins because he makes the premise charming and likable.

They conclude that progress won the movie, with Obama cited as the broader cultural beneficiary.

They close by naming Morgan Freeman as the film's winner, with Robbins acknowledged as a strong co-lead.

They close by naming Eddie Murphy the clear winner of the movie.

They agree that Goldman won the movie because the script became a landmark success and transformed his career.

They agree Spike Lee won because the film made his career and stands as one of the greatest American movies.

At the end, they agree that Glenn Close won the movie.

They initially land on Rosamund Pike, then both shift to Fincher after discussing the movie's Hitchcock lineage and craft.

They explicitly crown Chong Li as the movie's winner because the character is so memorable and iconic.

Bill explicitly picks Cruise as the winner, with Foxx acknowledged as a strong second choice.

They end by agreeing that Jeremy Renner won the movie, with Affleck's directing also credited for the overall success.

Tarantino is the clear winner for turning the debut into a major career-launching success, with Roth noted as a favorite performance runner-up.

They clearly agree that Tom Cruise wins the movie.

The hosts explicitly conclude that Tarantino wins the movie, while also crediting Waltz as the performance that made it work.

The group debates Billy Crystal versus Nora Ephron and revisits Meg Ryan's importance, but the conversation ends without a clean unanimous winner.

The final consensus lands on Tommy Lee Jones as the movie’s winner because his character gives the film its soul and emotional frame.

Rachel McAdams is the final pick, though Ryan Gosling gets a strong case for the relationship dynamics and dialogue.

They directly agree that Robin Williams wins the movie, with some support for Robert Sean Leonard as a secondary choice.

They conclude that The Rock won the movie because this role launched him into the version of his career he has now.

They ultimately pick Galifianakis as the movie's winner because he became the breakout star and still dominates the comedy.

They agree Common has the biggest non-Keanu boost because Cassian feels iconic and worthy of Wick.

The final consensus leaned to Rachel McAdams because the role launched her career and created an all-time character, even though Lohan was at her peak.

They finish by arguing over the best performer and ultimately split, with Charlie Sheen winning the host’s vote and Wesley Snipes taking the guest’s.

They explicitly choose Robert Redford as the winner of the movie, with a brief nod that Brimley's chest hair could be argued as a joke alternative.

They ultimately give the movie to Segel because he wrote and stars in it, though Kunis gets a strong shout as the breakout.

After revisiting the question at the end, they stick with Winona Ryder as the person who won the movie.

Kevin Kline is named the winner of the movie, with Ving Rhames getting a shoutout.

They choose Cooper for directing, starring, and conceiving the film, with Gaga acknowledged as also hugely important to its success.

Bill ultimately votes for New York, citing the rain-soaked city photography and the movie’s city-as-character feel.

After debating Brian versus Dom, they ultimately land on Vin Diesel as the movie's winner.

They debate several candidates, but Coppola gets the final consensus as the primary winner of the movie.

After weighing the behind-the-scenes story against the on-screen performance, they settle on Val Kilmer as the movie's winner.

They land on Dave Grusin's score as the thing that most wins the movie, since it most strongly gives the film its lasting identity.

They explicitly choose Jason Robards as the movie’s winner over Redford and Hoffman.

They debate McConaughey versus Linklater, but conclude the movie is best credited to Linklater because it launched his career and is the film’s overall masterpiece.

They ultimately agree that Tarantino won because the movie cemented his voice and set up the next phase of his career.

They end by choosing Malkovich as the movie’s winner, though Damon gets a serious counter-case.

They explicitly say Liam Neeson wins the movie and even the broader action-movie moment around it.

They close by saying Vince Vaughn is the overall winner of the movie because his performance is the peak of the film.

Bill ultimately gives the movie to Julia Roberts, while acknowledging Rupert Everett's scene-stealing performance and Cameron Diaz's strong showing.

In the final judgment, the room names Bruce Willis as the winner, with Rickman and McTiernan also argued as possible answers.

They conclude Tom Cruise won the movie because Ethan Hunt carries the whole enterprise.

After debating Ferrell versus Reilly, they settle on Adam McKay as the overall winner because his direction makes the movie work.

After considering the whole field, they agree Spielberg won the movie, with Shaw singled out as the strongest alternate case.

They conclude Tom Hanks won the movie because he carries nearly every major challenge of the performance and the film.

The final consensus is that the T-Rex wins the movie, with Goldblum and Spielberg discussed but not chosen.

The final winner of the movie is Sorkin, with the hosts crediting the script, dialogue structure, and its synergy with editing and score.

One host picks Wallace Shawn while the other picks Andre the Giant, so there is no shared winner.

Sean argued the movie was a huge win for Nolan, while Andrew made the case for Tom Hardy.

In the final winner discussion, they split briefly among the leads before settling on John Goodman as the movie's winner.

They explicitly choose Jordan Peele as the overall winner of the movie.

They close by giving the movie to Farrell, saying his performance is the thing they associate most strongly with the film.

The panel explicitly agrees that James Van Der Beek won the movie.

They explicitly agree that Heath Ledger wins the movie.

They ultimately give the movie to Fincher for the depth of scholarship and control on display.

They agree that Eddie Murphy is the clear winner of the movie over Nick Nolte and Walter Hill.

The episode ends with an explicit consensus that Chris Tucker won the movie.

The episode closes by stating that Heath Ledger clearly won the movie.

After some back-and-forth, they choose Matthew Lillard as the film’s winner.

Alicia Silverstone is named the clear winner of the movie.

They debate Kate Winslet versus Leonardo DiCaprio, but the conversation never lands on a firm final consensus before moving on.

Sandra Bullock gets three voices in her corner, while Keanu Reeves gets one firm vote.

When asked to choose the movie’s winner, they explicitly settle on Jonathan Demme.

They agree that Leonardo DiCaprio won the movie, with Matt Damon as the main alternative if needed.

They initially agree Tom Cruise won the movie, with Nicholson getting the main counterargument.