Rewatch IndexEvery Rewatchables episode
Back to the movie index

THE REWATCHABLES · January 17, 2023

Alive

A 1993 drama / disaster directed by Frank Marshall, covered in the complete Rewatchables archive.

DramaDisaster1990sDirected by Frank Marshall
Overall episode#291Source sheet order
Movie year19931990s
Tomatometer63%Critics’ score
Metacritic56View score
Roger Ebert—No review recorded
DirectorFrank MarshallDrama / Disaster

FROM THE CONVERSATION

What they said about the movie

The hosts frame Alive as a brutal true-story survival movie that also plays like a secret sports movie and a 'what would you do?' dilemma. They praise the plane crash, Ethan Hawke's second-half turn, the moral tension around cannibalism, and the group dynamics, while noting the movie is long and slows in the middle.
Based only on this episode’s transcriptTimes approximateSpeakers were clearly identifiedExplore the connections

WHY IT WORKS

What made it rewatchable

  1. 01The plane-crash sequence is described as astonishing and one of the best crash scenes in movies. About 24 min
  2. 02The movie generates constant 'what would you do?' debate, especially around survival cannibalism. Opening minutes
  3. 03The group-survival and hierarchy dynamics keep inviting rewatches and discussion. About 8 min
  4. 04Ethan Hawke's performance, especially after the coma, gives the movie a strong late-game gear shift. About 8 min
  5. 05The movie's moral/religious conversations about souls, sin, and necessity are unusually compelling for a survival thriller. About 16 min

WHAT DID NOT WORK

Their main criticisms

  1. moderateThe movie is too long and slow in the middle. About 8 min
  2. moderateThe social-dynamics material does not fully culminate. About 8 min
  3. moderateThe cast is uneven, with some actors not fully landing. About 8 min
  4. minorThe film underplays the nastiness of the cannibalism compared with the hosts' curiosity about the real event. About 24 min

SCENES THEY KEPT COMING BACK TO

Standout moments

Favorite

The plane crash

The catastrophic crash is described as terrifying, well-cut, and one of the best in movie history.

About 24 min
Favorite

The 'we've got to eat' conversation

The ethical debate about eating the dead is treated as the movie's central dramatic scene.

About 24 min
Favorite

Nando and Canessa's final hike

The mountain trek and the line 'We're going to die walking' are singled out as rousing.

About 32 min
positive

The rescue helicopter

The helicopter pickup is viewed as a satisfying payoff, even if it is embellished relative to real life.

About 40 min
positive

The triage scene after the crash

The improvised medical treatment is cited as a strong survival-movie beat.

About 24 min
positive

The false rescue celebration

A brief hope that they have been found is discussed as a classic false-hope beat.

About 24 min

WHERE THEY DISAGREED

The biggest debates

They agreed Opening minutes

Is Alive primarily a sports movie or a survival movie?

Bill Simmons

It is basically a secret sports movie with team-beats and a championship-style hike.

Chris Ryan

It still works as a survival movie, but the sports structure is what makes it rewatchable.

They partly agreed About 24 min

How graphic should the cannibalism have been?

Craig Horlbeck

The movie should have shown more of the eating and made it nastier.

Bill Simmons

The restraint probably kept it from becoming too much, but the topic is inherently provocative.

They partly agreed About 8 min

Is the middle of the movie too slow?

Bill Simmons

Yes, the film drags when the survivors mostly huddle around and suffer.

Chris Ryan

The slower stretches still build the social order and moral tension.

No final agreement About 1:12 · medium confidence

Would they have survived better if they had moved sooner?

Bill Simmons

Maybe they should have taken the trip earlier or pushed out sooner.

Chris Ryan

The danger, weather, and lack of resources make second-guessing easy from the outside.

They partly agreed About 1:04

Who should have been captain?

Bill Simmons

Nando may have been a better leader than Antonio.

Chris Ryan

The captaincy mattered less than the emergency hierarchy that emerged.

11 People discussedActors, directors, writers, and producers
10 Conversation takesSpeakers shown only where the transcript identifies them
Bill SimmonsLiked it

Alive as a secret sports movie

Argues the film follows sports-movie beats, with a ragtag team, adversity, and a climactic journey.

Opening minutes
Chris RyanLiked it

Alive as a rewatchable true-story survival film

Says the movie works because the characters feel contemporary to him and the premise invites endless debate.

Opening minutes
Craig HorlbeckLiked it

altruistic cannibalism

Revisits his hot take that the cannibalism is ethically legible because it serves the greater good.

Opening minutes
Bill SimmonsLoved it

the plane crash

Calls the crash sequence extraordinary and the movie's signature set piece.

About 24 min
Chris RyanLoved it

the religious and moral debate scenes

Says the conversations about souls, priests, and morality are the most compelling parts.

About 16 min
Bill SimmonsLoved it

Ethan Hawke

Argues Hawke is excellent and may wind up with many rewatchable performances over time.

About 32 min
Bill SimmonsLiked it

the score

Says the main theme is gorgeous and part of what makes the movie work.

About 40 min
Craig HorlbeckMixed

the cannibalism depiction

Wants the movie to show the eating as uglier and more visceral.

About 24 min
Bill SimmonsMixed

the film's pacing

Finds the middle section slow and repetitive even though the premise is riveting.

About 8 min
Chris RyanLiked it

the movie's moral dilemma engine

Says the movie's power comes from a genuine moral dilemma that forces viewers to choose sides.

About 32 min
5 ThemesThe larger ideas in the discussion

Survival ethics

The episode repeatedly returns to whether cannibalism becomes justified as a necessity and how people rationalize it.

Opening minutes

Sports-movie structure

Bill argues the film follows underdog sports beats, with a team, adversity, leadership, and a climactic journey.

Opening minutes

Faith and mortality

The religious background of the characters and the film's soul/body arguments make the situation feel biblical.

About 16 min

Hierarchy under pressure

The hosts are fascinated by how a team hierarchy forms in crisis, including leaders, helpers, complainers, and drifters.

About 8 min

Physical deprivation

Food, cigarettes, toothpaste, smell, and cold are treated as major survival details that shape the movie's texture.

About 24 min
25 Facts and referencesProduction notes and other movies mentioned

Production note

The real Andes crash happened in 1972, and the film is based on a book about the survivors.

Opening minutes

Production note

The movie was filmed in sequence so the actors could look progressively thinner and rougher.

About 48 min

Production note

Ethan Hawke refused to grow a beard and kept a goatee instead.

About 56 min

Production note

The cast fasted for two days before filming the eating-dead conversation.

About 1:04

Production note

The crew filmed in the Canadian Rockies, not the actual Andes.

About 1:04

Production note

A 2005 expedition recreated the journey and found the road they had missed.

About 48 min

Production note

The real survivors initially downplayed the cannibalism before the backlash forced them to address it.

About 1:04 · medium confidence

Mentioned with uncertainty

The hosts joke that the real plane had an implausibly large cigarette supply.

About 40 min · medium confidence

Production note

The film's real survivors included a technical advisor credit for Nando Parrado.

About 1:04

Production note

The real rescue helicopters were not exactly as staged in the film.

About 40 min · medium confidence

Remember the Titans

Used as a model for sports-movie beats and team adversity.

Opening minutes

Hoosiers

Referenced as another example of a team-movie setback moment.

Opening minutes

Major League

Used as another sports-beat comparison.

Opening minutes

Apollo 13

Cited as an earlier example of a true-story disaster movie people could experience as history.

Opening minutes

13 Lives

Mentioned as a modern equivalent to a harrowing true-story rescue movie.

About 8 min

Yellowjackets

Used as a cannibalism-and-survival comparison.

About 16 min

Jaws

The inevitable cannibalism beat is compared to waiting for the shark reveal.

About 24 min

The Grey

Mentioned as another strong plane-crash or survival film.

About 24 min

Cast Away

Used repeatedly as the strongest survival comparison and crash reference.

About 24 min

Fearless

Named as a favorite plane-crash movie and survival comparison.

About 24 min

Sully

Mentioned in the plane-crash discussion as a near miss rather than a crash.

About 24 min · medium confidence

The Revenant

Raised as another survival movie benchmark.

About 1:12

Cannibal Holocaust

Used as a cannibalism-film comparison.

About 1:12

Sweeney Todd

Discussed as a possible cannibalism-related film reference.

About 1:12 · medium confidence

The Verdict

Referenced as an apex cigarette-smoking movie.

About 1:12 · medium confidence
10 Running jokes and short linesRecurring bits captured from the conversation

Cannibalism ethics riff

The hosts repeatedly joke about rankings, cuts of meat, and whether they'd eat specific body parts first.

About 16 min

Cigarette accounting

They obsess over how many cigarettes the survivors could possibly have had and how long they lasted.

About 40 min

Fantasy as the least mountain-ready person

The hosts joke that Fantasy would steal the cigarettes and abandon the group.

About 1:04

Wayne Jenkins-style overacting/voice bit

They drift into a stylized dramatic voice and joking recasts, including Wayne Jenkins references.

About 1:12 · medium confidence

'We're going to die walking' as slogan

The line becomes a repeated motivational punchline for the final hike.

About 32 min

Bill Simmons

“Alive is a secret sports movie”
Opening minutes

Bill Simmons

“If we die, we're going to die walking”
About 32 min

Bill Simmons

“The plane crash is unbelievable”
About 24 min

Craig Horlbeck

“This is why we're doing the pod”
About 16 min

Bill Simmons

“We didn't eat your sister”
About 1:12 · medium confidence

MAKE IT A MOVIE NIGHT

Where to watch

UNITED STATES

Checking where Alive is available…

WHAT TO WATCH NEXT

Movies to watch before and after.

Three movies to watch before Alive, and three to watch next.

Finding six movies…Three to watch first and three to watch next.
Includes a Rewatchables episodePosters from TMDB.

ON THE MIC

3 voices on this episode

Bill Simmons headshotBill SimmonsThe Rewatchables
Chris Ryan headshotChris RyanThe Rewatchables
Craig HorlbeckThe Rewatchables

REWATCH FAVS

One of your favorites?

Upvote it for the live listener ranking.

YOUR PROGRESS

Save this one to your tracker

Sign in with Google only when you want to save progress. The rest of the site stays public.

KEEP LISTENING

Hear the full conversation

Play the episode directly from the official feed, open it on Spotify, or save it to your private Listen Later playlist.