Rewatch IndexEvery Rewatchables episode
Back to every decision

THE REWATCHABLES · October 15, 2024

The Silence of the Lambs (Live from New York)

A 1991 thriller / horror movie directed by Jonathan Demme—and decision no. 28 in the Hanks–Cruise tape.

ThrillerHorror1990sDirected by Jonathan Demme
The Silence of the Lambs (Live from New York)1991MOVIE
Podcast episode#366No. 377 overall
Movie year19911990s release
Tomatometer95%No. 9 of 128 tracked
Metacritic86View score
Roger Ebert4/4Original star rating
State of the raceHanks led by 215–13 · 0 ties

FROM THE CONVERSATION

What they said about the movie

The panel treats The Silence of the Lambs as a near-perfect prestige thriller: terrifying, highly rewatchable, tightly constructed, and culturally enormous. They argue it helped mainstream true-crime obsession, elevated serial killers as pop-culture figures, and made Hopkins' Hannibal Lecter one of cinema's most indelible villains. The discussion is affectionate, jokey, and reverent, with frequent praise for Demme's direction, Foster's performance, and the film's restraint around gore.
Based only on this episode’s transcriptTimes approximateSpeakers were clearly identifiedExplore the connections

WHY IT WORKS

What made it rewatchable

  1. 01Iconic first Lecter/Clarice encounter, with unmatched dialogue and character work. About 32 min
  2. 02The Migs spitting scene and the surrounding prison banter are absurdly memorable. About 40 min
  3. 03The van abduction sequence builds dread through staging, music, and perspective. About 40 min
  4. 04Lecter's escape from the guards is a centerpiece scene that redefines the movie's energy. About 48 min
  5. 05The final basement confrontation and night-vision sequence deliver maximum suspense. About 48 min

WHAT DID NOT WORK

Their main criticisms

  1. minorThe accent for Clarice is a weak point for some of the panel. About 16 min
  2. moderateJack Crawford is portrayed as reckless and badly trained. About 1:52
  3. minorThe anagram/clue mechanics can feel a little clunky compared with the rest of the movie. About 1:44
  4. moderateThe movie's transphobia-related controversy is noted as a lasting problem. About 2:08
  5. minorThe Chianti pairing and Miggs' tongue-violation logic are treated as a bit dubious in hindsight. About 2:08

SCENES THEY KEPT COMING BACK TO

Standout moments

Favorite

First Clarice-Lecter interview

Clarice meets Lecter in prison; the scene establishes the movie's power, their chemistry, and Miggs' gross interruption.

About 32 min
Favorite

Migs spitting scene

Miggs throws bodily fluid at Clarice after Lecter needles him, creating a disgusting but iconic beat.

About 40 min
Favorite

Van abduction with Tom Petty

Catherine helps move a couch into a van and is abducted, with 'American Girl' playing over the sequence.

About 40 min
Favorite

Lecter's guard attack/escape

Lecter kills the guards, hangs one as a display, and escapes in a hugely memorable burst of violence.

About 48 min
positive

Clarice interviews Senator Martin and then Lecter again

The movie's central investigative conversations intensify the bond between Clarice and Lecter.

About 56 min
Favorite

Buffalo Bill's basement reveal and standoff

Clarice enters Bill's lair, realizes the trap, and faces the night-vision terror in the basement.

About 48 min

WHERE THEY DISAGREED

The biggest debates

They partly agreed Opening minutes

Is the movie horror or thriller?

Bill Simmons

leans thriller with horror elements

Chris Ryan

thriller, not straightforward horror

Mallory Rubin

psychological terror more than slasher horror

No final agreement About 16 min

Best Actor or Supporting Actor for Hopkins

Sean Fennessey

best actor; supporting would distort the Oscars that year

Bill Simmons

supporting would have been the better category move

Mallory Rubin

best actor because Lecter is the primary figure

They left it as a friendly argument About 1:36

Most rewatchable scene

Chris Ryan

Lecter's guard attack

Mallory Rubin

crying of the lamb story

Bill Simmons

first Clarice-Lecter encounter

They partly agreed About 2:00

What aged worst

Sean Fennessey

the sequel/prequel franchise decisions and later Hannibal material

Bill Simmons

the opening-credit graphics and profiling tropes

Mallory Rubin

the movie's transphobia controversy

They agreed About 1:52

Weak link / most reckless character

Chris Ryan

Jack Crawford is the weak link because he is reckless and sloppy

Mallory Rubin

investigation/puzzle mechanics are clunky, though not a fatal flaw

14 People discussedActors, directors, writers, and producers
very favorableAnthony HopkinsBill Simmons: Praised as a career-making, ice-cold, iconic Lecter whose stillness and menace define the movie. About 8 min very favorableJodie FosterSean Fennessey: Praised for a determined, deeply human Clarice performance and career-defining toughness. About 24 min very favorableJonathan DemmeChris Ryan: Credited with making the film feel human, terrifying, and distinctively his without feeling like his other movies. About 16 min favorableTed LevineSean Fennessey: Praised as an unforgettable Buffalo Bill, especially for the laughably unsettling quality of the character. About 32 min
neutralThomas HarrisIdentified as the novelist behind the Lecter books and related adaptations. About 48 min
favorableRoger EbertBill Simmons: Referenced as giving the film three and a half stars and praising its suspense and horror. About 56 min neutralGene HackmanBill Simmons: Mentioned as a casting what-if who reportedly had development involvement. About 2:08 favorableMichelle PfeifferMallory Rubin: Discussed as an alternate Clarice who might have changed the movie's tone and sexuality. About 2:08 neutralPaul VerhoevenSean Fennessey: Mentioned as another director who could have made a more openly sexual version. About 2:08 · medium confidence
neutralEd GeinChris Ryan: Cited as part of Buffalo Bill's real-life inspiration. About 32 min
neutralGary HeidnikChris Ryan: Cited as inspiration for the dungeon/pit element of Buffalo Bill. About 32 min
neutralTed BundyChris Ryan: Mentioned as part of Buffalo Bill's composite inspiration. About 32 min favorableHoward ShoreMallory Rubin: Praised for the score and needle-drop support around the film's suspense. About 40 min favorableWilliam GoldmanSean Fennessey: Credited with suggesting the film cut a major hearing sequence, improving the final edit. About 1:44
12 Conversation takesSpeakers shown only where the transcript identifies them
Bill SimmonsLiked it

The Silence of the Lambs as a horror/thriller

Frames the movie as scary but more of a thriller and a prestige adaptation than a conventional horror film.

Opening minutes
Chris RyanLoved it

true-crime boom

Argues the movie helped popularize modern true-crime culture and serial-killer fascination.

About 8 min
Sean FennesseyLoved it

Hannibal Lecter

Treats Lecter as one of the most indelible movie characters ever and a central reason the film works.

About 8 min
Mallory RubinLoved it

first Lecter meeting

Chooses the first Clarice-Lecter meeting as her favorite scene, especially because of Miggs and the setup.

About 1:36
Chris RyanLoved it

Jonathan Demme's direction

Says Demme makes the movie feel humane and distinct even while making mainstream horror-thriller material.

About 16 min
Bill SimmonsLoved it

Anthony Hopkins

Argues Hopkins is a career-redefining star whose Lecter performance is instantly recognizable.

About 8 min
Sean FennesseyLoved it

Jodie Foster

Says Foster's performance set the template for her later career as a strong, accomplished lead.

About 24 min
Mallory RubinLoved it

Clarice Starling

Calls Clarice a rare female-protagonist role that still feels timeless and powerful.

About 24 min
Chris RyanDid not like it

Jack Crawford

Criticizes Crawford as reckless, underqualified, and badly handling the investigation.

About 1:52
Mallory RubinLiked it

Buffalo Bill's basement battle

Treats the night-vision final confrontation as deeply scary and expertly foreshadowed.

About 48 min
Sean FennesseyLiked it

Buffalo Bill

Finds Bill more funny and entertaining than purely terrifying.

About 32 min
Bill SimmonsLoved it

Lecter's escape

Calls the guard attack and escape one of the great scenes of the last 35 years.

About 48 min
5 ThemesThe larger ideas in the discussion

True-crime mainstreaming

The panel argues the movie helped launch modern true-crime fascination and made serial-killer media mainstream.

About 8 min

Female-protagonist procedural

Clarice is presented as a rare, highly effective female lead navigating powerful male institutions.

About 24 min

Psychological horror over gore

The film is described as terrifying largely through implication, performance, and psychology rather than explicit violence.

About 24 min

Villain as star

Lecter is treated as the movie's gravitational center and one of cinema's most unforgettable characters.

About 8 min

Prestige adaptation

The film exemplifies the era when acclaimed books were being turned into major, awards-heavy movies.

Opening minutes
23 Facts and referencesProduction notes and other movies mentioned

Production note

The film was the first and only horror film to win Best Picture, and it won the Big Five Oscars.

Opening minutes

Production note

Hopkins appears for only about 24 minutes and 52 seconds.

About 8 min

Production note

The film grossed about $272.7 million on a $19 million budget.

About 48 min

Production note

The movie was largely shot in Pittsburgh even though it is set in Baltimore.

About 2:08

Production note

Ted Levine's Buffalo Bill was inspired by Ed Gein, Gary Heidnik, and Ted Bundy.

About 32 min

Production note

Brooke Smith reportedly gained 25 pounds for the role of Catherine Martin.

About 2:08

Production note

The Lecter mask was made by Ed Cubberly, a New Jersey goalie-mask maker.

About 2:08

Production note

William Goldman suggested cutting the disciplinary hearing sequence, and the cut improved the film.

About 1:44

True crime podcasts

Used as a comparison for Clarice's outsider-investigator energy and the film's influence on modern true-crime fascination.

About 8 min

CSI

Mentioned as part of the rise of crime-entertainment TV after the film's era.

About 8 min

OJ trial

Referenced as a pop-culture turning point in the rise of crime obsession.

About 8 min

Darth Vader

Used as a shorthand for rooting for an iconic villain.

About 8 min

The Joker

Used to illustrate another instantly recognizable villain character.

About 8 min

Thelma & Louise

Referenced as part of an early-90s wave of strong female characters.

About 24 min

Misery

Referenced as another early-90s film with a memorable female lead.

About 24 min

Jaws

Used as an analogy for a movie with a visible villain and an obstructive local authority figure.

About 1:44

Poltergeist

Referenced in a discussion of other films with an obvious non-supernatural human villain.

About 1:44

The Shining

Mentioned as another grounded, prestige-adjacent scary movie that the speaker likes.

About 2:08

Manhunter

Discussed as the earlier Lecter adaptation and a great companion double feature.

About 1:44

Heat

Used when discussing Ted Levine's later casting and the desire to break him out of Buffalo Bill typecasting.

About 32 min

JFK

Referenced in the Oscar discussion and as the movie that affected Best Actor/Best Picture outcomes that year.

About 16 min

Philadelphia

Referenced as the film Demme made after Silence and as a possible reason for his regret about the film's controversy.

About 2:08

The Father

Used in a hot take about Hopkins' best performance.

About 2:08
11 Running jokes and short linesRecurring bits captured from the conversation

Mets/Phillies banter

Bill keeps interrupting the intro with Mets and Phillies chatter before pivoting to the movie.

Opening minutes

Worcester date-story / Jame Gum as funny

Bill repeatedly explains he found Jame Gum funny on a college date and says the internet later validated that reaction.

Opening minutes

Physical-media / Premiere magazine flex

Bill jokes about old magazines, eBay, and physical media as proof of his Hopkins-accent research.

About 8 min

Multiple Migs

The panel jokes about whether Migs means multiple personalities, repeated orgasms, or a single mononym.

About 40 min

Buffalo Bill Cribs / Love It or List It

They humorously map Bill's basement dungeon as though it were a real-estate tour.

About 32 min

State Farm/Paramount Plus sponsor riffs

The live episode includes repeated sponsor shout-outs and mock-serious applause cues.

About 32 min

Bill Simmons

“I ate his liver with fava beans”
About 40 min

Bill Simmons

“It rubs the lotion on its skin”
About 48 min

Mallory Rubin

“You fucking bitch”
About 56 min

Chris Ryan

“You look like a rube”
About 40 min

Bill Simmons

“I do wish we could chat longer”
About 56 min

MAKE IT A MOVIE NIGHT

Where to watch

UNITED STATES

Checking where The Silence of the Lambs (Live from New York) is available…

WHAT TO WATCH NEXT

Movies to watch before and after.

Three movies to watch before The Silence of the Lambs, and three to watch next.

Finding six movies…Three to watch first and three to watch next.
Includes a Rewatchables episodePosters from TMDB.

ON THE MIC

4 voices made the call

Bill Simmons headshotBill Simmons125 tracked appearances · 56 H / 64 C / 5 ties
Chris Ryan headshotChris Ryan77 tracked appearances · 36 H / 38 C / 3 ties
Sean Fennessey headshotSean Fennessey35 tracked appearances · 15 H / 17 C / 3 ties
Mallory Rubin headshotMallory Rubin12 tracked appearances · 4 H / 6 C / 2 ties

REWATCH FAVS

One of your favorites?

Upvote it for the live listener ranking.

YOUR PROGRESS

Save this one to your tracker

Sign in with Google only when you want to save progress. The rest of the site stays public.

KEEP LISTENING

Hear the full conversation

Play the episode directly from the official feed, open it on Spotify, or save it to your private Listen Later playlist.