THE CATEGORY
CABINET

They liked the Bogotá hotel and Colombian setting best, despite noting the country’s dislike of the depiction.

After trading a few 1995 markers, they pick the BMW Z3 as the movie’s most distinctly 1995 element.

Jessica Hecht is singled out as the best supporting character actor, with MC Ganey also discussed.

They give best actor to Eddie Bracken as Mr. Duncan and also praise Ralph Foody as the gangster in the black-and-white film.

After excluding a few candidates, they land on W. Earl Brown's Warren as the clear performance winner.

The band-actor aside ends with James Dolan as the most absurdly successful example of an actor/frontman crossover.

They agreed the back-seat armored-truck job is the worst because it is the danger spot when things go bad.

They admire the teaching-use concept for movies in class, but do not identify a winner.

The category becomes a proposed future ranking rather than a completed decision.

Before Midnight is treated as the devastating benchmark.

For non-squad or cameo-style support, they give the win to Sizemore, with Giamatti and Cranston getting shout-outs.

In a rapid rundown of Coughlin's Laws, the crabs line drew the clearest approval, with a few other absurd aphorisms also singled out.

After ranking several Philip K. Dick adaptations, they land on Blade Runner as the best overall film.

They discuss it as a live-odds framing device for movie moments, but do not choose a concrete winner.

Chris Cooper wins again, this time for the standout testimony scene.

They highlight the weather-based origin of the phrase Pineapple Express and also mention the snicklefritz weed name backstory.

They floated several reunion concepts, but the discussion never settled on one clear answer.

This closing riff is mostly impression comedy, so it doesn’t produce a supportable single winner.

They endorse a straightforward best-character-name category while citing classic examples like Mitch McDeere and Kelly Leak.

Ali Boomaye is the clear favorite name, with Bundini mentioned as a secondary option.

When Harry Met Sally gets the edge among New Year's Eve romantic comedies.

They singled out O'Hara and Levy's long-running partnership as a major reason the movie works.

Jon Voight's entire look wins the hair-and-facial-hair category, though Noonan's wheelchair detail gets strong support.

They float a month devoted to Best Picture winners without settling on a specific title.

The group builds a star-heavy cameos lineup centered on Penny, Shaq, Allen Houston, Calbert Cheaney, and George Lynch.

They pick Joey Trotta as the strongest horse-name candidate, with Toy Soldier also mentioned.

Mallory’s pick for best racehorse name was Cocas’s sister.

They pick Henry’s 'never rat on your friends' line as the best yearbook quote candidate.

When they split up the supporting-player awards, they went with Norton as the best seventh-man type presence.

They clearly identify John Doolan as the best stack guy in the movie.

When they turn to best supporting, Bill Murray is the clearest choice, with Bacon mentioned as another standout.

Dave names Dustin Hoffman as the winner, while Bill makes a strong case for John Leguizamo.

Paul Avery is chosen as the best tang, while Zodiac himself is jokingly identified as the worst tang.

The best-thing pick leans toward Gosling's daughter and the worst-thing pick lands between Blueface and Chet, with Chet getting the clearest support.

They clearly pick the green apple as the movie's best food-and-drink detail.

They treat the cockroach scene here as the better and more effective version.

A reaction shot from Jack Ross is singled out as an especially strong face category pick.

They agree Friar Tuck’s mead is the best food-and-drink item in the movie.

The dinner sequence won for its comic use of the wine, peas, and table tension.

The beer reaction and the kitchen prep sequence are the main food-and-drink moments they praise, with the beer edging it out.

They focus on the tooth treatment and restaurant details, with the clove oil extract coming off as the clearest food/drink-related choice.

They choose the meal at the lodge as the best food-and-drink moment, with the local dinner scene also getting praise.

The uneaten diner cheeseburger gets the nod for best food-and-drink detail, with Mr. Softy discussed but not eligible because it never appears on screen.

The dead cat sandwich is the clear winner for the most memorable food-and-drink beat.

They settle on the moment when Hathaway breaks a wine bottle and immediately uses it as a weapon.

They agree the milk is the best use of food or drink in the movie.

They land on the burrito thrown at Fat Amy as the most notable food moment, even though they dislike what it signals in the scene.

They jokingly allow cigarettes and give the award to Mike finding the last loose cigarettes in his pack.