Rewatch IndexEvery Rewatchables episode

THE REWATCHABLES FIELD GUIDE · VOL. 02

THE CATEGORY
CABINET

Every recurring ritual, one-off fever dream, winner, and open debate we could responsibly pull from the podcast transcripts.

Transcript derivedNo host-by-host vote ledger
Episodes processed266 / 478

56% of the complete archive

Category calls5,226

Every mention stays traceable

Winners resolved88%

4,573 transcript-supported picks

Cabinet drawers1,025

Reviewed regulars + preserved oddities

START WITH THE REGULARS

Six cards everyone knows.

Uneven edges. Very serious filing.
251 episodesApex Mountain223 episodesWhat's Aged the Worst?213 episodesWhat's Aged the Best?185 episodesCasting What-Ifs185 episodesThe “That Guy” Award180 episodesMovie Memorabilia

THE COMPLETE FIELD INDEX

Pull open a drawer.

Search a category, movie, episode, or logged winner.
914 files625–672 shownClear filters
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Big Kahuna Burger award, Best use of food and drinkA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Mar 7, 2023
Latest logged
Mar 7, 2023

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusMar 7, 2023 · ~40:00
    The Purge · 2013Queen Cersei's no-carbs dinner and giant glass of wine

    They land on the absurdity of making a low-carb dinner on Purge night, with the wine helping sell the bit.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Bill Simmons Hardcore AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode0% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
0
Left open
1
First logged
Jan 20, 2025
Latest logged
Jan 20, 2025

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

0 winners on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Left openJan 20, 2025 · ~1:20:00
    A 2025 Rewatchables MailbagNo clear winner recorded

    They float it for the most inappropriate work-computer Google search prompted by a movie, but never crown a winner.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEthe Billy Bats Jack Waltz award for best insultA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jan 5, 2026
Latest logged
Jan 5, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJan 5, 2026 · ~1:28:00
    A 2026 Rewatchables MailbagGet your fucking shine box

    They settle on 'get your fucking shine box' as the most usable insult in real life.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Billy Batts Jock Jock Waltz Award for most biting and scalable insultA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Jun 14, 2026
Latest logged
Jun 14, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredJun 14, 2026 · ~58:00
    The Hand That Rocks the Cradle · 1992"When your husband makes love to you, it's my face he sees."

    They single out that line as the film's sharpest insult.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEthe brandy booth award for best performance by a petA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Dec 20, 2022
Latest logged
Dec 20, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredDec 20, 2022 · ~56:00
    I Am Legend · 2007sam

    Sam the dog wins easily as the movie's best pet performance.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Brandy Booth Award for best performance by a petA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Oct 15, 2024
Latest logged
Oct 15, 2024

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredOct 15, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    The Silence of the Lambs (Live from New York) · 1991Precious

    Precious the dog won the pet-performance award.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Breakfast Club real long inspection award / Die Hard 2 Yippee-Ki-Yay Mr. Falcon award / The Big Lebowski find a stranger in the opposite awardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode0% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
0
Left open
1
First logged
Jun 4, 2026
Latest logged
Jun 4, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

0 winners on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Left openJun 4, 2026 · ~16:00
    A Rewatchables Summer Mailbag!No clear winner recorded

    The hosts discuss several possible names for a new TV profanity-replacement category but never settle on a single winner or final title.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Carl from Walking Dead AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jan 20, 2025
Latest logged
Jan 20, 2025

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJan 20, 2025 · ~1:20:00
    A 2025 Rewatchables MailbagJem

    They use it for the character most likely to survive a zombie apocalypse, with Jem and Buck as the examples they like most.

    Runner-up · Buck
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEthe category of the actor I can't believe did not become a bigger starA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Feb 17, 2025
Latest logged
Feb 17, 2025

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredFeb 17, 2025 · ~1:04:00
    Wayne's World · 1992Dana Carvey

    They spend the segment arguing that Dana Carvey had the talent and exposure to become a much bigger movie star than he did.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Catherine Trammell, would you throw your life away for this obvious stay-away awardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jul 13, 2026
Latest logged
Jul 13, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJul 13, 2026 · ~1:38:00
    She's the One · 1996Cameron Diaz’s character

    Diaz’s Heather is the obvious dangerous choice, though the room notes multiple temptations in the movie.

    Runner-up · Amanda Peet’s character
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Catherine Trammell, would you throw your life away for this obvious stay-away award?A bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
May 4, 2026
Latest logged
May 4, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusMay 4, 2026 · ~1:18:00
    There's Something About Mary · 1998Mary

    They treat Mary as the obvious stay-away because of the sheer number of psychos orbiting her.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEthe Chris Coughlin awardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode0% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
0
Left open
1
First logged
Jan 5, 2026
Latest logged
Jan 5, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

0 winners on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Left openJan 5, 2026 · ~1:04:00
    A 2026 Rewatchables MailbagNo clear winner recorded

    They discuss it as a ‘throw your life away for this woman’ type of category, but leave it open-ended.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Chris Ryan award for "I don't understand the choice"A bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jan 27, 2025
Latest logged
Jan 27, 2025

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJan 27, 2025 · ~1:04:00
    Before Sunrise · 1995the film's lack of smoking

    Chris Ryan argued that not having the characters smoke in this era was the movie choice he least understood.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Cliff Booth Award for is this movie better if the main character had a pet?A bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode0% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
0
Left open
1
First logged
Jul 12, 2022
Latest logged
Jul 12, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

0 winners on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Left openJul 12, 2022 · ~1:44:00
    Top Gun: Maverick · 2022No clear winner recorded

    They joked about Cruise with a dog, but the discussion did not support a real case that a pet would improve the movie.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Clint Howard award for the director loves this guyA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Sep 3, 2024
Latest logged
Sep 3, 2024

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredSep 3, 2024 · ~40:00
    Night Shift · 1982Clint Howard

    Clint Howard won the award named for the director’s favorite recurring collaborator.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Clint Howard Award for the director loves this guyA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
May 13, 2024
Latest logged
May 13, 2024

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredMay 13, 2024 · ~2:00:00
    Jerry Maguire · 1996Eric Stoltz

    They note Cameron Crowe's habit of putting Eric Stoltz in his movies and give him the award.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Clint Howard Award for The Director loves this guyA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jul 29, 2024
Latest logged
Jul 29, 2024

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJul 29, 2024 · ~3:04:00
    Pulp Fiction (Part 1 and 2) · 1994Samuel L. Jackson

    They treated Jackson as the clearest example of a Tarantino favorite, with Tim Roth also mentioned as a recurring favorite.

    Runner-up · Tim Roth
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEthe Craig Horbachev Century Club AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode0% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
0
Left open
1
First logged
Jan 5, 2026
Latest logged
Jan 5, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

0 winners on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Left openJan 5, 2026 · ~1:20:00
    A 2026 Rewatchables MailbagNo clear winner recorded

    They define it as the question of whether a movie would be better if it were exactly 100 minutes long, but do not rank a specific title.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Dan Waiters AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Mar 7, 2023
Latest logged
Mar 7, 2023

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredMar 7, 2023 · ~48:00
    The Purge · 2013Grace, the crazy female neighbor

    They pick Grace as the memorable oddball neighbor, while noting the son also has a strange energy.

    Runner-up · the son
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Dan Wethers AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Sep 20, 2022
Latest logged
Sep 20, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredSep 20, 2022 · ~1:20:00
    Margin Call · 2011Paul Bettany

    Because the field is crowded, they give the Dan Wethers-style supporting spot to Paul Bettany.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEthe Dana Wheeler-Nicholson AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jan 5, 2026
Latest logged
Jan 5, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJan 5, 2026 · ~1:20:00
    A 2026 Rewatchables MailbagMia Sara

    They treat Mia Sara as the cleanest example of a great actress who should have had a much bigger career.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Danny McBride Award for best job playing yourselfA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Jun 27, 2023
Latest logged
Jun 27, 2023

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredJun 27, 2023 · ~1:12:00
    This Is The End · 2013Danny McBride

    They create a new award for best job playing yourself and immediately give it to Danny McBride.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Deanie Waiters AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Dec 11, 2018
Latest logged
Dec 11, 2018

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredDec 11, 2018 · ~52:00
    The Firm · 1993Wilford Brimley

    Brimley is declared the winner after an extended riff on how much menace and oddity he brings to the movie.

    Runner-up · Holly Hunter
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Den of Thieves Benihana Award for scene stealing locationA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Jan 24, 2023
Latest logged
Jan 24, 2023

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredJan 24, 2023 · ~56:00
    Big · 1988Playland

    They give the location award to Playland, with the Ferris wheel moments as part of the case for it.

    Runner-up · the Ferris wheel scenes
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Den of Thieves Benihana Award for scene-stealing locationA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Jun 2, 2022
Latest logged
Jun 2, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredJun 2, 2022 · ~40:00
    Cop Land · 1997Four Aces

    Four Aces gets the award, though the George Washington Bridge is briefly discussed as another strong location contender.

    Runner-up · the George Washington Bridge shootout
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Den of Thieves Benny Hanau Award for Scene-Stealing LocationA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Dec 15, 2025
Latest logged
Dec 15, 2025

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredDec 15, 2025 · ~1:12:00
    High Fidelity · 2000the Green Mill

    Rob names the Green Mill as the scene-stealing location during the four-versions-of-Ian discussion.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Den of Thieves Benny Hanna award for scene stealing locationA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jul 26, 2022
Latest logged
Jul 26, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJul 26, 2022 · ~1:08:00
    There Will Be Blood · 2007the bowling alley

    The bowling alley emerges as the top scene-stealing location, with the Pacific Ocean also getting strong support.

    Runner-up · the Pacific Ocean
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Den of Thieves Benny Hanno award for scene stealing locationA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Apr 25, 2023
Latest logged
Apr 25, 2023

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusApr 25, 2023 · ~56:00
    Sudden Death · 1995the arena roof

    They say the roof is the standout location, though the whole arena works as a scene-stealing setting.

    Runner-up · the whole arena
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Den of Thieves Benny Hondo Award for the scene-stealing locationA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Jul 12, 2022
Latest logged
Jul 12, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredJul 12, 2022 · ~56:00
    Top Gun: Maverick · 2022The Hard Deck

    The Hard Deck won easily as the movie’s standout bar setting and the kind of place the hosts said they would actually visit.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe den of thieves, Benihana award for scene stealing locationA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jul 5, 2022
Latest logged
Jul 5, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJul 5, 2022 · ~56:00
    Misery · 1990The basement

    They settle on the basement as the movie's most scene-stealing location, with the Four Seasons as the only real alternative.

    Runner-up · The Four Seasons restaurant
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Denethy’s Benihana Award for scene stealing location in the houseA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Jun 25, 2026
Latest logged
Jun 25, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredJun 25, 2026 · ~56:00
    The Good Son · 1993The house in Rock Harbor

    The award goes to the Rock Harbor house as the scene-stealing location, with the desert briefly mentioned as another strong setting choice.

    Runner-up · The desert/Arizona opening location
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEthe Dennis Peck relationship testA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Jan 13, 2026
Latest logged
Jan 13, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredJan 13, 2026 · ~56:00
    What Lies Beneath · 2000no real test; dennis peck could break them up

    They agree Dennis Peck would easily get between Norman and Claire if given a chance.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Denny Thieves Benihana AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Oct 17, 2023
Latest logged
Oct 17, 2023

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusOct 17, 2023 · ~56:00
    So I Married An Axe Murderer · 1993the hotel

    They treat the hotel as the standout location and also single out the poetry place as a nice setting.

    Runner-up · the poetry place
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe DeonA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Apr 2, 2024
Latest logged
Apr 2, 2024

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredApr 2, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    Shot Caller · 2017Holt McCallany as the Beast

    After listing several nominees, they settle on Holt McCallany's Beast as the movie's standout supporting performance.

    Runner-up · Jon Bernthal as Shotgun
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEthe Deshaun Jackson AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode0% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
0
Left open
1
First logged
Jan 5, 2026
Latest logged
Jan 5, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

0 winners on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Left openJan 5, 2026 · ~1:20:00
    A 2026 Rewatchables MailbagNo clear winner recorded

    They float it for movies that drop the ball at the one-yard line, but do not land on a single title.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Devil Wears PradaA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Dec 29, 2025
Latest logged
Dec 29, 2025

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredDec 29, 2025 · ~1:20:00
    Bill’s 50 Most Rewatchable Movies of the 21st CenturyThe Devil Wears Prada

    Bill reveals it as his number one because it is the movie he has watched the most this century.

    Runner-up · The Social Network
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEthe Diane Keaton Kay Adams award for Best Actor or Actress in a Poorly Written Character RoleA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jan 5, 2026
Latest logged
Jan 5, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJan 5, 2026 · ~1:20:00
    A 2026 Rewatchables MailbagKay Adams in The Godfather

    They settle on Kay Adams as the archetype of a great performer stuck in a poorly written role, while also citing Padmé as a comparable example.

    Runner-up · Padmé Amidala in the Star Wars prequels
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Doctor Claire Lewicki Award for worst character nameA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Mar 17, 2025
Latest logged
Mar 17, 2025

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredMar 17, 2025 · ~48:00
    Days of Thunder · 1990Dr. Claire Lewicki

    They decide Dr. Claire Lewicki is the weakest name in the movie because it feels mismatched with the character and setting.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Don Dawson-Sasha Jenkins awardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jan 20, 2025
Latest logged
Jan 20, 2025

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJan 20, 2025 · ~48:00
    A 2025 Rewatchables MailbagDana Wheeler-Nicholson

    They define it as the actor who should have become a much bigger star, with Dana Wheeler-Nicholson as the example they land on first.

    Runner-up · Eliza Dushku
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Dorfler's door award for how much that hurt isA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Apr 27, 2026
Latest logged
Apr 27, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredApr 27, 2026 · ~1:18:00
    Ghostbusters · 1984Venkman getting slimed

    They pick the slime attack on Venkman as the moment that looks most physically unpleasant.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Dr. Richard Kimball Inappropriate Body AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jul 12, 2022
Latest logged
Jul 12, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJul 12, 2022 · ~56:00
    Top Gun: Maverick · 2022Tom Cruise's shredded body

    The hosts marveled that Cruise is improbably yoked in the Mojave and treated his physique as the clear winner.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Dr. Richard Kimball Inappropriate Body AwardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Oct 3, 2023
Latest logged
Oct 3, 2023

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusOct 3, 2023 · ~56:00
    Toy Soldiers · 1991multiple jacked teens and the sit-up guy

    They note that several younger characters and even an older student are improbably muscular for the setting.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Dracula of the musical award for best imitation of real artA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Sep 13, 2022
Latest logged
Sep 13, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredSep 13, 2022 · ~1:04:00
    Singles · 1992Touch Me I'm Dick

    They pick Citizen Dick’s “Touch Me I’m Dick” as the best fake-song imitation.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEthe Dracula the Musical awardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
May 31, 2022
Latest logged
May 31, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusMay 31, 2022 · ~1:04:00
    The New Categories Selection ShowDracula the Musical

    They agree the vampire-musical example is good enough to become a recurring 'was that actually good?' type category.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Dracula, the musical award for best artA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
1
Left open
0
First logged
Jul 5, 2022
Latest logged
Jul 5, 2022

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Apparent consensusJul 5, 2022 · ~56:00
    Misery · 1990The Misery books

    They praise the novel-within-the-movie concept and land on the Misery books as the best art choice.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Dwayne Stevenson sweater vest missed opportunity awardA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode0% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
0
Apparent
0
Left open
1
First logged
Jun 4, 2026
Latest logged
Jun 4, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

0 winners on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. Left openJun 4, 2026 · ~16:00
    A Rewatchables Summer Mailbag!No clear winner recorded

    Bill likes the idea of the category but vetoes it, so no winner is chosen.

    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Ed Norton reverse dunk award did this movie need a random sports momentA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Mar 16, 2026
Latest logged
Mar 16, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredMar 16, 2026 · ~1:20:00
    To Live And Die In L.A. · 1985the Quentin Daly / Bulls sports tangent

    They agreed the out-of-nowhere Quentin Daly sports chatter was the movie’s best random sports moment.

    Runner-up · Rick Masters not playing pickup basketball
    Episode
ONE-NIGHT-ONLY FILEThe Ed Norton reverse dunk award for did this movie need a random sports scene?A bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.1episode100% resolved
Calls logged
1
Declared
1
Apparent
0
Left open
0
First logged
Jun 25, 2026
Latest logged
Jun 25, 2026

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

1 winner on file

Six most recent of 1 · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredJun 25, 2026 · ~1:18:00
    The Good Son · 1993No, the movie already had enough with the soccer scene

    They treat the existing soccer scene as the answer and agree the movie did not need another random sports insert.

    Episode