Rewatch IndexEvery Rewatchables episode

THE REWATCHABLES FIELD GUIDE · VOL. 02

THE CATEGORY
CABINET

Every recurring ritual, one-off fever dream, winner, and open debate we could responsibly pull from the podcast transcripts.

Transcript derivedNo host-by-host vote ledger
Episodes processed254 / 478

53% of the complete archive

Category calls5,007

Every mention stays traceable

Winners resolved88%

4,401 transcript-supported picks

Cabinet drawers977

Reviewed regulars + preserved oddities

START WITH THE REGULARS

Six cards everyone knows.

Uneven edges. Very serious filing.
239 episodesApex Mountain213 episodesWhat's Aged the Worst?207 episodesWhat's Aged the Best?175 episodesCasting What-Ifs174 episodesThe “That Guy” Award169 episodesMovie Memorabilia

THE COMPLETE FIELD INDEX

Pull open a drawer.

Search a category, movie, episode, or logged winner.
Complete registerTony Romo or Chris Collinsworth for the director's commentaryBack to index
One-night-onlyTony Romo or Chris Collinsworth for the director's commentaryA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.20episodes85% resolved
Calls logged
20
Declared
11
Apparent
6
Left open
3
First logged
Mar 5, 2024
Latest logged
Dec 30, 2024

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

17 winners on file

Complete register · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredDec 30, 2024 · ~1:20:00
    Friday Night Lights · 2004Tom Hanks

    With Craig as tiebreaker, Hanks gets the nod over Cruise for Coach Gaines.

    Runner-up · Tom Cruise
    Episode
  2. Apparent consensusDec 9, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    Disclosure · 1994Chris Collinsworth

    They favor Collinsworth for play-by-play commentary, while acknowledging Quentin as another strong option.

    Runner-up · Quentin Tarantino
    Episode
  3. DeclaredNov 11, 2024 · ~1:20:00
    Meet The Parents · 2000Scott Hansen

    They choose Scott Hansen as the ideal commentary voice over Romo or Collinsworth.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  4. DeclaredOct 15, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    The Silence of the Lambs (Live from New York) · 1991Chris Collinsworth

    Chris Collinsworth was picked for the imaginary commentary track, with Romo treated as the alternative.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  5. Apparent consensusOct 7, 2024 · ~1:04:00
    Poltergeist · 1982Chris Collinsworth

    They lean toward Chris Collinsworth as the best hypothetical commentary voice.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  6. DeclaredSep 24, 2024 · ~1:20:00
    Over The Top · 1987Gus Johnson

    They choose Gus Johnson as the ideal over-the-top play-by-play voice for a commentary track.

    Episode
  7. DeclaredAug 27, 2024 · ~2:00:00
    Purple Rain · 1984Tony Romo

    They explicitly pick Tony Romo for the commentary role.

    Episode
  8. DeclaredAug 13, 2024 · ~1:36:00
    The Grand Budapest Hotel · 2014Doris Burke

    They joked through a broadcaster-style commentary comparison and landed on Doris Burke as the funniest fit.

    Runner-up · Chris Collinsworth / Tony Romo
    Episode
  9. Apparent consensusAug 6, 2024 · ~1:04:00
    Dodgeball · 2004Tony Romo

    They prefer Romo's chaotic energy for a commentary track over Collinsworth.

    Episode
  10. DeclaredJul 9, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    Twister · 1996Doris Burke

    In the modified director's commentary category, Doris Burke is the clear pick, with Tony Romo also discussed as an option.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  11. Apparent consensusJul 2, 2024 · ~1:04:00
    The Naked Gun · 1988Both Tony Romo and Chris Collinsworth

    They imagined both broadcasters doing the commentary together and agreed that pairing would be ideal.

    Episode
  12. DeclaredJun 25, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    The Bad News Bears · 1976Chris Collinsworth

    They settle on Collinsworth as the better fit for the commentary style.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  13. Apparent consensusJun 18, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    The Longest Yard · 1974Chris Collinsworth

    They lean Collinsworth for the kind of football-color commentary that best matches the movie’s action.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  14. DeclaredMay 28, 2024 · ~1:36:00
    Fast Times at Ridgemont High · 1982Tony Romo

    The hosts choose Tony Romo's style for the imagined commentary track over Collinsworth's.

    Runner-up · Chris Collinsworth
    Episode
  15. DeclaredMay 13, 2024 · ~2:00:00
    Jerry Maguire · 1996The divorced women's support group scene

    They imagine commentator-style riffs on the divorced women's group scene as the funniest possible director's-commentary bit.

    Runner-up · Collinsworth-style commentary on Avery
    Episode
  16. DeclaredApr 30, 2024 · ~1:04:00
    The Running Man · 1987Tony Romo

    They choose Romo because the action and upset-heavy plot fit his style better.

    Runner-up · Chris Collinsworth
    Episode
  17. Left openApr 2, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    Shot Caller · 2017No clear winner recorded

    They riff on how absurdly specific prison-shank and handcuff mechanics are, rather than landing on a clean single winner.

    Episode
  18. Left openMar 26, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    Manchester By The Sea · 2016No clear winner recorded

    They skip this category rather than choosing between the two commentary-style options.

    Episode
  19. Left openMar 12, 2024 · ~1:20:00
    Risky Business · 1983No clear winner recorded

    They riff on either broadcaster doing the commentary rather than choosing one cleanly.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  20. Apparent consensusMar 5, 2024 · ~1:28:00
    Road House · 1989both together

    They conclude Romo and Collinsworth would both be great, especially if paired together.

    Episode