Rewatch IndexEvery Rewatchables episode

THE REWATCHABLES FIELD GUIDE · VOL. 02

THE CATEGORY
CABINET

Every recurring ritual, one-off fever dream, winner, and open debate we could responsibly pull from the podcast transcripts.

Transcript derivedNo host-by-host vote ledger
Episodes processed477 / 482

99% of the complete archive

Category calls7,647

Every mention stays traceable

Winners resolved85%

6,494 transcript-supported picks

Cabinet drawers1,234

Reviewed regulars + preserved oddities

START WITH THE REGULARS

Six cards everyone knows.

Uneven edges. Very serious filing.
449 episodesApex Mountain399 episodesWhat's Aged the Worst?383 episodesWhat's Aged the Best?341 episodesThe “That Guy” Award338 episodesCasting What-Ifs331 episodesWho Won the Movie?

THE COMPLETE FIELD INDEX

Pull open a drawer.

Search a category, movie, episode, or logged winner.
Complete registerTony Romo or Chris Collinsworth for the director's commentaryBack to index
One-night-onlyTony Romo or Chris Collinsworth for the director's commentaryA bespoke category preserved exactly as it appeared in the transcript-derived ledger.20episodes85% resolved
Calls logged
20
Declared
11
Apparent
6
Left open
3
First logged
Mar 5, 2024
Latest logged
Dec 30, 2024

THE TRANSCRIPT REGISTER

17 winners on file

Complete register · timestamps approximate
  1. DeclaredDec 30, 2024 · ~1:20:00
    Friday Night Lights · 2004Tom Hanks

    With Craig as tiebreaker, Hanks gets the nod over Cruise for Coach Gaines.

    Runner-up · Tom Cruise
    Episode
  2. Apparent consensusDec 9, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    Disclosure · 1994Chris Collinsworth

    They favor Collinsworth for play-by-play commentary, while acknowledging Quentin as another strong option.

    Runner-up · Quentin Tarantino
    Episode
  3. DeclaredNov 11, 2024 · ~1:20:00
    Meet The Parents · 2000Scott Hansen

    They choose Scott Hansen as the ideal commentary voice over Romo or Collinsworth.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  4. DeclaredOct 15, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    The Silence of the Lambs (Live from New York) · 1991Chris Collinsworth

    Chris Collinsworth was picked for the imaginary commentary track, with Romo treated as the alternative.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  5. Apparent consensusOct 7, 2024 · ~1:04:00
    Poltergeist · 1982Chris Collinsworth

    They lean toward Chris Collinsworth as the best hypothetical commentary voice.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  6. DeclaredSep 24, 2024 · ~1:20:00
    Over The Top · 1987Gus Johnson

    They choose Gus Johnson as the ideal over-the-top play-by-play voice for a commentary track.

    Episode
  7. DeclaredAug 27, 2024 · ~2:00:00
    Purple Rain · 1984Tony Romo

    They explicitly pick Tony Romo for the commentary role.

    Episode
  8. DeclaredAug 13, 2024 · ~1:36:00
    The Grand Budapest Hotel · 2014Doris Burke

    They joked through a broadcaster-style commentary comparison and landed on Doris Burke as the funniest fit.

    Runner-up · Chris Collinsworth / Tony Romo
    Episode
  9. Apparent consensusAug 6, 2024 · ~1:04:00
    Dodgeball · 2004Tony Romo

    They prefer Romo's chaotic energy for a commentary track over Collinsworth.

    Episode
  10. DeclaredJul 9, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    Twister · 1996Doris Burke

    In the modified director's commentary category, Doris Burke is the clear pick, with Tony Romo also discussed as an option.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  11. Apparent consensusJul 2, 2024 · ~1:04:00
    The Naked Gun · 1988Both Tony Romo and Chris Collinsworth

    They imagined both broadcasters doing the commentary together and agreed that pairing would be ideal.

    Episode
  12. DeclaredJun 25, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    The Bad News Bears · 1976Chris Collinsworth

    They settle on Collinsworth as the better fit for the commentary style.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  13. Apparent consensusJun 18, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    The Longest Yard · 1974Chris Collinsworth

    They lean Collinsworth for the kind of football-color commentary that best matches the movie’s action.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  14. DeclaredMay 28, 2024 · ~1:36:00
    Fast Times at Ridgemont High · 1982Tony Romo

    The hosts choose Tony Romo's style for the imagined commentary track over Collinsworth's.

    Runner-up · Chris Collinsworth
    Episode
  15. DeclaredMay 13, 2024 · ~2:00:00
    Jerry Maguire · 1996The divorced women's support group scene

    They imagine commentator-style riffs on the divorced women's group scene as the funniest possible director's-commentary bit.

    Runner-up · Collinsworth-style commentary on Avery
    Episode
  16. DeclaredApr 30, 2024 · ~1:04:00
    The Running Man · 1987Tony Romo

    They choose Romo because the action and upset-heavy plot fit his style better.

    Runner-up · Chris Collinsworth
    Episode
  17. Left openApr 2, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    Shot Caller · 2017No clear winner recorded

    They riff on how absurdly specific prison-shank and handcuff mechanics are, rather than landing on a clean single winner.

    Episode
  18. Left openMar 26, 2024 · ~1:12:00
    Manchester By The Sea · 2016No clear winner recorded

    They skip this category rather than choosing between the two commentary-style options.

    Episode
  19. Left openMar 12, 2024 · ~1:20:00
    Risky Business · 1983No clear winner recorded

    They riff on either broadcaster doing the commentary rather than choosing one cleanly.

    Runner-up · Tony Romo
    Episode
  20. Apparent consensusMar 5, 2024 · ~1:28:00
    Road House · 1989both together

    They conclude Romo and Collinsworth would both be great, especially if paired together.

    Episode