There's Something About Mary
15 winners · 0 left open
Who won the movie?
DeclaredCameron Diaz
After considering Stiller, Diaz, and Dillon, they ultimately choose Cameron Diaz as the person who won the movie.
Most rewatchable scene
Apparent consensusHealy meeting Mary at the golf course
The room converges on the golf-course meeting as the funniest and most rewatchable scene in the movie.
What's aged the best?
Apparent consensusThe movie's bad-taste comedy playing as pure joke material
They agree the film still works because its bad-taste material is played straight for laughs rather than as edgy drama.
Apex Mountain
DeclaredThe Farrelly brothers
Across the various Apex Mountain side discussions, they decide the Farrelly brothers as a duo are at their peak here.
Open the full ledger11 more categories, in podcast order↓
What's the most 1998 thing about this movie?
DeclaredCops being prominently involved in a scene
They settle on the use of Cops in the Woogie scene as the most unmistakably 1998 element.
What's aged the worst?
DeclaredBrett Favre and the Warren casting conversation
They identify Brett Favre's later baggage and, more seriously, the casting of Warren as the biggest thing that has aged poorly.
Casting What Ifs
DeclaredSteve Young for Healy, Chris Farley for Warren, Owen Wilson or Jon Stewart for Ted
They run through multiple alternate casts, with Steve Young, Chris Farley, Owen Wilson, Jon Stewart, Bill Murray, and Vince Vaughn all discussed as near-misses.
Best actor award, not eligible
DeclaredW. Earl Brown as Warren
After excluding a few candidates, they land on W. Earl Brown's Warren as the clear performance winner.
Dion Waiters
DeclaredKeith David
They settle on Keith David as the standout supporting wild-card performance in the movie.
Recasting couch / director city
Apparent consensusNorm Macdonald as Tucker
They toy with several recasts, but Norm Macdonald as Tucker emerges as the most compelling alternate version.
Top five most shocking and hilarious male nudity in a major comedy
DeclaredBorat
After a top-five list, they conclude Borat's hotel nude fight is the funniest male-nudity gag in a comedy.
The Catherine Trammell, would you throw your life away for this obvious stay-away award?
Apparent consensusMary
They treat Mary as the obvious stay-away because of the sheer number of psychos orbiting her.
Secret Handshake memorabilia you want from this movie
Apparent consensusWarren's earmuffs
They pick Warren's earmuffs as the funniest collectible prop from the movie.
Floyd Gondoli, butter my ass, lollipops in my mouth award for something I just enjoy
DeclaredA movie where everybody has a job but nobody works
They settle on the movie's deadbeat-but-employed world as the thing they most enjoy about it.
Double feature
DeclaredDumb and Dumber
For a pairing with this movie, they land on Dumb and Dumber as the best double feature choice.